Sports can be a cutthroat business, and the NBA is just one example of how true this statement is. Blown series and poor decisions can end careers faster than ink drying on a signed contract.
Yet Billy Donovan has been able to navigate coaching stops seamlessly. Despite a coaching ledger soaked in mediocrity, blown leads, and schematic shortcomings, Donovan glides along untouched.
He has now stepped down as head coach of the Chicago Bulls. He was not forced out. Instead, he declined the invitation from ownership to continue coaching the team so that the incoming front office could conduct a search for its own coaching staff.
Despite the fact that it appears he can do no wrong, Donovan’s NBA tenure has objectively been a failure, sustained mostly by elite talent and shielded by convenient narratives.
OKC Debacle — Superstars and Failure
Billy Donovan stepped into Oklahoma City in 2015 with a superstar-laden Thunder roster ready for championship contention. Kevin Durant and Russell Westbrook carried the load.
The team was supposed to summit the mountaintop and with the NBA Finals, that was the goal, and it was attainable. But in the 2016 Western Conference Finals, the Thunder blew a 3-1 lead against the Golden State Warriors.
Donovan was never the architect. He was the passenger. Durant and Westbrook dragged the squad with incredible talent. Later additions like Chris Paul, who elevated the Hornets and Clippers, helped keep the Thunder competing at a high level.
Donovan had other All-Stars and high-level role players. Including his tenure in Chicago, Paul George, Zach LaVine, DeMar DeRozan, Nikola Vucevic, Alex Caruso, and Coby White helped mask gaps. Donovan’s offense stagnated without them, and his defense leaked. Yet the excuses flowed with injuries, roster mismanagement, bad fortune providing a large shield.
Never the coach though.
Donovan, to his credit, admitted early on that he had very little to offer Durant and Westbrook when he started. But that humility should have raised alarms. Instead, his humbleness was spun as endearing.
Chicago’s Savior…Not Quite
The young talent of LaVine, White, Wendell Carter, and Lauri Markkanen was enough to entice Donovan’s leap from the Thunder to the Bulls.
Donovan’s faith in the Bulls future was solidified even more with the additions of Lonzo Ball, DeRozan, Vucevic, Caruso, and later Ayo Dosunmu.
The roster was by no means perfect, especially with the devastating injury to Ball. But it had enough to consistently reach the playoffs. Instead his schemes crumbled. The offense became predictable and iso-dependent.
Defense throughout his tenure remained inconsistent. And development lagged until Arturas Karnisovas upgraded the staff with sharper NBA minds.
Roster mismanagement, partly due to Donovan’s shortcomings, defined the era, delivering mostly Play-In exits and sub .500 stretches.
The Secret Extension: A Setup to Fail
Billy Donovan quietly secured his first contract extension before the full weight of the Bulls’ struggles hit. Reports indicate the deal was locked in while front office extensions for Karnisovas and Marc Eversley were still sorting.
The situation foreshadowed what was to happen with Donovan’s contract situation that was resolved in 2025, yet again before his boss’s. With the recent dismissals of Karnisovas and Eversley, Donovan remained fully insulated and publicly reaffirmed by ownership. He has now stepped down as head coach, but Bulls owner Jerry Reinsdorf publicly stated that they wanted Donovan to remain in his position.
From the outside, the argument could be made that Karnisovas was set up to fail as far back as four years ago. Leaked sentiments from inside the Bulls organization painted LaVine’s deal as dead weight that tied up the Bulls’ financial flexibility.
More leaks a few years later surfaced that general managers around the league had grown reluctant to trade with Karnisovas, viewing the Bulls’ assets and contracts as toxic.
The front office absorbed the blame for bad deals and poor returns on veterans, while Donovan’s job security stayed rock solid. The orchestrated optics worked perfectly; get extended early, let the execs take the heat, emerge unscathed.
Curious Staff Choices and Legacy Insurance
The Thunder’s rebuild choice spoke volumes. Rather than retaining the “culture builder” from Florida, the Thunder promoted Donovan’s assistant, Mark Daigneault, who has thrived.
In Chicago, he assembled a less dynamic bench, perhaps intentionally avoiding stars who might eclipse him or get poached.
No obvious successor on the sideline would mean less pressure if and when things went south.
Rumors of UNC interest? Likely a manufactured leverage play. The likelihood of Donovan returning back to college always seemed like a stretch. The landscape of the game has changed greatly, and Donovan would have been under immediate pressure to win right away.
It’s a far cry from the comfortable seat he has grown accustomed to in Chicago. Besides, his legacy was built off the college game, and failing would only taint what he meticulously built.
The UNC leak created even more leverage to cement his place on the Bulls bench and usurp more power away from Karnisovas.
Billy Donovan Was the Last Man Standing By Design
Somehow Billy managed to have more influence on the Bulls than proven past winners like Phil Jackson and Tom Thibodeau. He finagled security, outlasted the front office that hired him, and watched as Karnisovas took the fall for what should have been shared failures.
Now the Billy Donovan era is over, but the entirety of it took place on his terms, all the way to the finish line.
In Chicago, Teflon “Don”ovan didn’t need rings or wins. He could do no wrong because accountability never sticks.
Leave a comment