AFCAFC WestBroncosNFL

What Midseason Grades Do the Denver Broncos Get?

Share
Nov 6, 2025; Denver, Colorado, USA; Denver Broncos head coach Sean Payton talks with quarterback Bo Nix (10) during the second half at Empower Field at Mile High. Mandatory Credit: Isaiah J. Downing-Imagn Images
Isaiah J. Downing-Imagn Images
Share

What a time to be alive as a Denver Broncos fan.

So far this season, the Broncos have treated their fans to miraculous comebacks, incredible defensive play, and even a sputtering offense that transforms into fourth-quarter magic.

Some people are questioning how far Denver will go in the playoffs; others are simply wondering how they manage to even win games. Nevertheless, every team has its weaknesses and strengths, so what better time than now to dissect this erratic team?

Offense: D-

Disappointment. Anger. Hope. The actions the Denver Broncos’ offense elicits range from jumping out of the chair to throwing it away. A rollercoaster of emotions is but a glimpse at what this offense has given those who love the horsemen.

They’ve been shockingly bad in three quarters, to outright dominant in the fourth. Stats don’t lie, and sadly, these stats hurt.

Per Team Rankings, the Broncos are 20th in third-down conversion percentage (37.5%), 18th in yards per play (5.3), and 30th and 31st in penalties per game (8.7) and penalty yards per game (73.6). Self-inflicted wounds can’t summarize the inconsistencies blatantly displayed in an offense built with undeniable weapons.

However, running the ball has been a strong suit for Peyton and his Broncos. Ranked eighth in yards per rush (4.8) and ninth in rush yards per game (128.6), Denver has found unfamiliar success on the ground. Not to mention that Nix is a powerful runner at will.

A team that consistently struggled to find rushing success for almost a decade has found its missing link, which boosts its overall grade to a D-.

Coaching: C-

When looking at the Denver Broncos coaching staff, it may very well lead to the effects of some late-night Taco Bell. There’s a whole lot of flavor with massive risks involved.

It’s a tale of two sides. The defensive coaches this year have been outstanding. The offensive coaches, though? Abysmal.

Sean Payton really is a mastermind, so much so that it leads to his downfall. If Bo Nix has taught us anything, it’s that he knows how to throw a football. Three-yard check-down passes and wide screens are wonderful, especially to get him in the groove, but there needs to be more.

Too often, there’s a common theme in Denver’s games. Run the same offensive plays, paint them a different color, and expect the defense not to adjust.

If the Giants game didn’t convince Payton and crew what needs to change, nothing will. Nix needs to be let loose, to take more risks than just late in a miraculous fourth-quarter comeback.

This offense thrives when their wild child quarterback lets loose his inner Tasmanian devil.

Defense: A

There isn’t a soul in the NFL fandom who has yet to hear about Denver’s defense. Nine sacks against the New York Jets? Wow. Forcing an average of eight penalties a game? Scary. However, the story is not just about the improbable stats they create.

The Broncos’ defense throughout the entire season has single-handedly kept this team in the game, between inefficient offense, neck-and-neck scores, and even devastating turnovers. In spite of this, the Broncos’ defense has kept the wins rolling, due to the way they terrorize opposing offenses.

Not that they are perfect, not by any means. However, defenses like this are seldom built in the blink of an eye. Knowing a team is elite at every position is a sight to behold. Years of diligence, patience, and even questionable signings have led to this defensive powerhouse.

Overall: B

The Broncos have impressed when it seemed impossible, and have also left us with shocking disappointments. However, for a team that was a playoff contender last season, success seems to be on the horizon for Sean Payton’s Broncos.

Share
Written by
Tobias Swiney

Tobias is currently a junior at Liberty University studying a B.S. in Creative Writing: Journalism. From a young age he fell in love with football, and since then he has dedicated his time and efforts to turn his dream of analyzing and commentating professional football into reality. When he isn't writing articles about the Denver Broncos, you can catch him hosting his own podcast with his brother Seth.

Leave a comment

Related Articles
May 1, 2026; Philadelphia, PA, USA; Philadelphia Eagles wide receiver Makai Lemon (9) runs drills during rookie minicamp at NovaCare Complex. Mandatory Credit: Bill Streicher-Imagn Images
EaglesNFCNFC EastNFLNFL Draft

How Will Each Philadelphia Eagles Rookie Fit In With the Team?

After the 2026 NFL Draft, there are eight new Philadelphia Eagles rookies,...

Dec 25, 2025; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; Denver Broncos quarterback Bo Nix (10) rolls out to pass during the second half against the Kansas City Chiefs at GEHA Field at Arrowhead Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jay Biggerstaff-Imagn Images
AFCAFC WestBroncosNFL

Ranking Every Broncos Starting Quarterback Since 2020

In 2015, Peyton Manning played his last year of football with the...

Feb 24, 2026; Indianapolis, IN, USA; Buffalo Bills general manager Brandon Beane speaks at the NFL Scouting Combine at the Indiana Convention Center. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images
AFCAFC EastBillsNFL

How Should We Grade the Bills’ Last Five First Round Picks?

The past few drafts have been chaos for the Buffalo Bills. Between...

Jun 10, 2026; Foxborough, MA, USA; New England Patriots tackle Caleb Lomu (74) speaks to the media after minicamp at Gillette Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Eric Canha-Imagn Images
AFCAFC EastNFLPatriots

How Will Caleb Lomu Fit into the Patriots’ Plans?

In the New England Patriots’ crushing Super Bowl LX defeat against the...