The Pittsburgh Steelers lost on Sunday night to the Cincinnati Bengals 38-18, dropping to 6-3. Cincinnati had their way with Pittsburgh on both sides of the ball. Joe Burrow and Ja’Marr Chase torched the Steelers’ secondary, with Chase catching 11 passes for 231 yards. Cincy’s defense sacked Aaron Rodgers three times and held the Steelers offense to 34 yards in the first three quarters, according to TruMedia.
The loss puts Pittsburgh in a tough spot in the race for the AFC North. Even though they split the Bengals series, Cincinnati will only face two teams currently over .500 the rest of the way: the Cleveland Browns twice and the Kansas City Chiefs. Meanwhile, Pittsburgh will face the Jacksonville Jaguars and Denver Broncos, and will still have the Baltimore Ravens twice, potentially with Lamar Jackson back.
The Steelers had a four-game win streak entering their bye last week. They looked completely different in this game, as if they had not practiced at all this year.
“It’s not to the standards of the Pittsburgh Steelers,” head coach Mike McCarthy said.
This was easily the team’s worst performance of 2026. The only thing they can do about this is move on and focus on winning the rest of their games. But how can this team respond after a brutal loss like this? The Steelers have the answers right in front of them. Whether they commit to what works is entirely on them.
The Tight End, Run-Heavy Offense Works
Going into the bye, running back Jaylen Warren was playing at an All-Pro-caliber level. He had more than 130 total yards and more than 5 yards per carry in three of those games. Still, an ugly pattern reared its head early in Sunday’s game: Warren had only five touches in the first half. Tight end Darnell Washington had his lone catch in the first half, and Pat Freiermuth had none at the halfway point.
Cincinnati’s first two drives led to two touchdowns, totaled 172 yards and took about 14 minutes off the clock. The Steelers’ first drive, sandwiched in between Cincy’s two drives, gained only three yards and ticked a minute. A swing pass to Jaylen Warren, a run up the middle for three yards and an incomplete pass to DK Metcalf.
“We wanted to play a sort of style of game, but we never really got into it,” said McCarthy.
McCarthy spoke about the team’s momentum during halftime and after the game, particularly about how he needed to help the team establish an offensive flow. Still, he continues to trot out 11 personnel with a depleted receiving room. He wants to establish the pass first, and that hasn’t worked for the Steelers.
More Under Center and Play Action Offense
The Steelers offense clicks when Jaylen Warren makes plays. It also functions when Rodgers goes under center. In their Week 3 win against the Bengals, Pittsburgh averaged more than nine yards per play and rushed for almost 100 yards within 22 plays. The shotgun plays totaled 37, but they only mustered over 5 yards per play.
Offensive coordinator Brian Angelichio said Monday that the offense needs to attack the middle of the field more, adding that play action could help in that area.
“You hear Mike [McCarthy] say all the time, ‘the quickest way is through the middle of the field,’ and play action can help us in that area,” Angelichio said.
Even with their strong running game, the Steelers have a play action rate of over 19%. Their lack of play action is confusing, given Warren’s success carrying the ball all year. It is even more baffling because Rodgers has seen a lot of success in play action, posting a top-five EPA per play and top-ten success rate. In non-play action, both stats are third-worst and worst in the league.
Angelichio also emphasized the need to avoid long downs, which they failed to do on Sunday. The Steelers were 0/7 on third-down conversions in the first three quarters, with six of those being third-and-longs. This kept them away from play-action scenarios, but it circles back to their failure to establish the run early in the game.
Lots of Season Left to Rebound
Ultimately, this is the first game under McCarthy where both sides of the ball were punked. A game like this can rupture locker rooms and derail promising seasons. The Steelers will not let that happen.
“We’re going to pull together and get the answers,” defensive coordinator Patrick Graham said on Monday.
The good news for Pittsburgh is that next week they face a Philadelphia Eagles team in shambles, sitting at 2-7. The bad news is they haven’t won in Philly since 1965. Regardless, this is a prime opportunity to build momentum before playing the Broncos on Black Friday.
The season is not lost yet, but the Steelers need to keep it afloat.
Leave a comment