AFCAFC EastBillsNFL

James Cook is the Most Underrated Running Back in the NFL

Share
Nov 15, 2026; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; Buffalo Bills running back James Cook III (4) celebrates after a game against the New York Jets at MetLife Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images
Nov 15, 2026; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; Buffalo Bills running back James Cook III (4) celebrates after a game against the New York Jets at MetLife Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images
Share

When discussing the Buffalo Bills, it’s easy to get lost in the things Josh Allen does for the franchise. However, his backfield partner, James Cook, deserves some of the light, too.

For the last four seasons, Cook has been one of the best running backs in football. The Georgia product has earned three straight Pro Bowls and a Second Team All-Pro nod in that span. Behind only Gibbs, Robinson, and McCaffrey, Cook is arguably the next best running back in football. 

Even on Cook’s own team, he’s sometimes overlooked. The truth is, though, the Bills wouldn’t be where they are without him. So, what makes James Cook so underrated?

Cook Is Second in Rushing Yards and Tied a Tomlinson Record

On the year, James Cook currently has 187 carries for 971 yards and nine touchdowns. This places him second in carries and rushing yards, sixth in rushing touchdowns, and fifth in yards per carry with 5.2.

Obviously, with more carries, a player will have higher counting stats. In Cook’s case, though, he continues to be an efficient runner despite carrying a heavy workload.

Some of Cook’s most impressive work this year lies in his last eight games. Last Sunday, he tied LaDainian Tomlinson for the most consecutive games with 75 or more rushing yards and one or more touchdowns, a record that Tomlinson has held since 2006.

Cook has also tied his franchise record of eight consecutive games with a touchdown, which he set last year.

While 2026 is shaping up to be another great year for Cook, his previous two were just as good. In 2024, he led the league with 16 rushing touchdowns. The following year, in 2025, he led the league with 1,621 yards and 95.4 yards per game.

This year he’s taken another step, averaging 107.9 rushing yards per game. Without this level of production, the Bills would have to rely on Josh Allen even more than they already do.

Cook’s ball security and pass-catching still leave something to be desired, but those concerns fade when the production is this consistent. 

The talent is undeniable, and certainly deserves more award recognition. For all Cook’s production, he’s rarely in discussion for individual awards. Not that he’d beat out the likes of Gibbs or Jaxson Smith-Njigba for Offensive Player of the Year, but he’s earned at least a top-five finish.

Cook Has Delivered Every Time the Bills Have Needed Him in January

One thing that James Cook has going for him is his playoff production. Since becoming the starter in 2023, Cook has consistently risen to the occasion in the postseason.

He got some playing time in the 2022 playoffs, but the year after is when things took off. Since then, he’s averaged 82.1 rushing yards per game. While the touchdown numbers are down, it’s not alarming.

The Bills often turn to Josh Allen on designed runs come playoff time, so Cook doesn’t have as many chances. When his number is called, he still delivers, though.

In the 2024 AFC Championship Game, Cook had 85 yards and two rushing touchdowns on just 13 carries. He also added three catches for 49 yards.

If the Bills want to make another deep playoff run, they need to deploy him more. The more balanced the offense can be, the harder they are to stop. When the offense is firing on all cylinders, they’re almost impossible to stop.

It all comes down to the other players on the roster. With the duo of Allen and Cook, it makes it easier on the rest of the team around them. The role players can play more freely, and Joe Brady can trust his best players.

Look for another postseason of impressive James Cook performances. 

The Numbers Say Top Five, But the Awards Don’t Reflect It

Year in and year out, Cook produces. He led the league in rushing yards last season, earned Second-Team All-Pro honors, and still didn’t receive a single first-place vote for Offensive Player of the Year.

That probably won’t change this year. With Gibbs putting together another elite season, the top individual awards are likely out of reach again.

But the lack of hardware doesn’t change what the tape and the numbers show. Cook is a top-five running back in football, and he has been for three years.

The Bills know it. Their opponents know it.

Eventually, the rest of the league will catch up.

The Daily Diehard Newsletter

Join the Diehards!

Up-to-date league coverage every weekday!

Select list(s):

We don’t spam! Unsubscribe at any time

Share
Written by
Ben Staker - Bills Contributor

Ben Staker is graduate of Millersville University in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, where he majored in journalism with a minor in sports studies. Outside of writing about the Buffalo Bills for The Lead, he also enjoys watching the NBA, NHL, MLB, and NLL. Ben has been writing for publication since his internship at the Hummelstown Sun during his Senior year of high school. In the years since then, he's worked as a sports editor and managing editor at Millersville University's newspaper 'The Snapper'.

Leave a comment

Related Articles
Oct 25, 2026; Baltimore, Maryland, USA; Baltimore Ravens running back Derrick Henry (22) runs the ball during the second quarter against the Cincinnati Bengals at M&T Bank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jamie Sabau-Imagn Images
AFC NorthNFLRavens

What Does Derrick Henry’s Slow Start Mean for His Legacy?

On Monday, Nov. 16, Derrick Henry suited up against the Los Angeles...

Nov 1, 2026; Arlington, Texas, USA; Dallas Cowboys head coach Brian Schottenheimer on the sidelines against the Arizona Cardinals during the fourth quarter at AT&T Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kevin Jairaj-Imagn Images
CowboysNFC EastNFL

The Dallas Cowboys Have Many Midseason Issues To Address

Overall, the Cowboys’ start to the 2026 NFL season has been a...

Nov 15, 2026; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) walks off the field following a loss to the Cincinnati Bengals at Paycor Stadium.
AFCAFC NorthFeaturedNFLSteelers

How do the Steelers Respond After a Brutal Loss?

The Pittsburgh Steelers lost on Sunday night to the Cincinnati Bengals 38-18,...

Nov 15, 2026; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow (9) throws downfield during the fourth quarter against the Pittsburgh Steelers at Paycor Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Katie Stratman-Imagn Images
NFL

Who Are The Top Five NFL MVP Candidates?

As the 2026 NFL season moves into Week 11, the race for...