The New York Knicks and Indiana Pacers have been in a dogfight of a series. After a heroic comeback win in Game 3 of the Eastern Conference Finals on the road in Indiana, they threw their rabid fanbase of dogs a bone. A fanbase that was dejected after going down 2-0 at Madison Square Garden had some life again. Knicks fans had hope.
But their hope is rapidly disappearing now. The Knicks crumbled under the weight of their own mistakes on Tuesday night, leading to a 130-121 loss.
Defensive lapses, along with silly turnovers, missed shots, and a flurry of head-scratching decisions from officials, dominated the loss to the Indiana Pacers.
It wasn’t just one thing that doomed the Knicks—it was a storm of issues, all colliding at the worst possible time you could think of.
Turnovers and Missed Opportunities
The Knicks turned the ball over 17 times in Game 4, leading directly to 20 points for the Pacers. In a playoff game, handling the basketball like elementary schoolers is a death sentence, no matter who you’re playing against.
Josh Hart, typically a steadying presence, had one of his roughest outings of the postseason. Hart was still able to manage a double-double, scoring 12 points with 11 rebounds. The versatile wing committed five turnovers and fouled out late in the fourth quarter, right when the Knicks needed his usual composure and grit.
Mikal Bridges, another playoff hero for much of this run, couldn’t find his rhythm either from the jump. Despite nailing a few buckets in the fourth, Bridges missed several key three-pointers down the stretch, including one off a designed play. His shooting slump contributed to a Knicks cold streak that saw multiple open looks clank off the rim, just when they were clawing their way back.
Jalen Brunson and Karl-Anthony Towns cannot do it all come crunch time, and if the Knicks have any plans of making a comeback, they will need more production from their other starters.
Fans were quick to question head coach Tom Thibodeau’s rotation. Thibodeau has expanded the bench in this series, with Delon Wright, Landry Shamet, and Precious Achiuwa all making abnormal appearances.
In the second half, Thibodeau chose to stick with Hart instead of tapping further into a bench that had helped spark a run to put the Knicks back in the game.
The most criticized decision, however, was opting for Landry Shamet instead of Miles McBride in the closing minutes. When asked about the move postgame, Thibodeau offered little clarity, saying he wanted “just a little more size.”
Knicks and Pacers Benches
One of the main storylines throughout this series has been the play of the Pacers bench. Indiana has had many different sparks off the bench throughout the playoffs, but they’re looming largest here in the Eastern Conference Finals, especially compared New York’s bench.
The Pacers bench has outscored the Knicks’ by a sizable margin every single game throughout this series, even with the Knicks expanding theirs during Games 3 and 4. Indiana brings difference makers off the bench. Bennedict Mathurin, T.J. McConnell, and former Knick Obi Toppin have come up big in some crucial moments, such as Toppin’s three-pointer that iced the game in the final minute of Game 4.
Meanwhile, the Knicks No. 1 option off the bench, Cameron Payne, has been abysmal ever since the playoff opener against Detroit. Payne has turned the ball over seven times in the limited action he has seen this postseason, racking up 22 fouls along the way; not what you usually look for from your top bench player.
Deuce McBride, on the other hand, has improved as the playoffs have progressed. He put together some 10+ point performances in the last round against Boston and has been solid against Indiana. He’s averaged 6.1 points per game throughout the playoff run while providing some defensive urgency.
The Knicks scored 21 bench points in Game 4. Mathurin scored 20 points off the bench alone for Indiana. When the entirety of your bench is getting outscored by a single player, that’s an issue. Tom Thibodeau is going to have to work with what he has to try and find something in Game 5 to stave off elimination. Resources are barren, but regardless, the Knicks need more production.
Sloppy Defense: No Communication, No Resistance
From the start of Game 4, the Knicks appeared disoriented on defense. A trend that has occurred frequently in this series. They gave up 43 points in the first quarter alone. For comparison, the Knicks only gave up 42 points in the second half of Game 3 — that strong defense set the stage for the comeback victory.
The defensive communication was nonexistent. Center Mitchell Robinson owned up to it after the game, saying, “Communication, that was the biggest thing. It started with me. I wasn’t talking first, and I’m the anchor of the defense. I’m not talking, nobody is.”
The lack of cohesion was glaring, especially since the Knicks were constantly getting beaten on switches, a big storyline throughout the series. The Knicks allowed 13 unanswered points late in the first half, watching a one-point lead balloon into a 12-point deficit by halftime.
The Pacers capitalized on every breakdown. Pascal Siakam bullied his way to 30 points, while Tyrese Haliburton orchestrated a masterclass. He racked up 32 points, 15 assists, and 12 rebounds, shredding the Knicks’ defense. New York had no answer.
With 22 fast break points, 13 made threes, and constant movement, Indiana ran a track meet. The Knicks could not keep up. The Pacers were constantly finding open looks all over the floor, catching the Knicks on switches and late recoveries all evening long.
A Rough Night for the Refs
As if their miscues weren’t enough, the Knicks also had to battle the whistle—or lack thereof.
One of the most jarring moments came when OG Anunoby was hacked on the head by Siakam while going for an offensive rebound. The impact sent Anunoby flying and left fans—and Anunoby himself—stunned by the no-call. Towns was shoved on the same play, with no whistle.
Then came a bizarre sequence: four touch fouls were called on the Knicks in 12 seconds. These fouls left fans and players scratching their heads in disbelief. Meanwhile, video evidence circulating on social media showed multiple blatant fouls by Indiana going uncalled. Mathurin and Siakam were dragging Knicks players to the ground, and Mathurin trucked Shamet in what looked more like a football play than a basketball play.
There was a lot of grabbing and hand-fighting between the two teams last night, but it was shocking not to hear the whistle blown on multiple occassions.
A widely shared screenshot even caught T.J. McConnell stepping out of bounds in the fourth quarter.
To many Knicks fans, it felt like déjà vu from previous playoff disappointments. Social media was buzzing with frustration, with some even going so far as to say the game was “rigged.”
Still, the Knicks cannot afford to get in their heads and lose their composure. They must focus on the game, as hard as it may be.
Looking Ahead
The Knicks have consistently demonstrated resilience throughout the season. They will need every ounce of it to bounce back from down 3-1. But if Tuesday night proved anything, it’s that even a talented, gritty team like the Knicks can’t survive self-inflicted wounds.
In the high-stakes pressure cooker of the playoffs, attention to detail and consistency are non-negotiable. It is the playoffs, and you have to be on your A-game no matter what. The Knicks have their backs against the wall. They may be without Karl-Anthony Towns, who is listed as questionable for Game 5 after suffering a knee injury in Game 4.
Game 5 is set for tonight at 8:00 PM at The Garden between the Knicks and Pacers.
Leave a comment