MLB

Who Are the Most Underrated MLB Free Agents at Each Position?

Share
Jun 27, 2026; Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA; Chicago Cubs left fielder Ian Happ (8) rounds the bases after hitting a home run against the Milwaukee Brewers in the sixth inning at American Family Field. Mandatory Credit: Michael McLoone-Imagn Images
Credit: Michael McLoone-Imagn Images
Share

This free agency isn’t like most free agencies in Major League Baseball.

The coming labor lockout on Dec. 2 is going to rock the world of baseball. Nobody knows how the sport will look once it’s over. There might be a salary cap for the first time in MLB’s over 150-year history. There might not be.

This made players’ agents skittish. Nobody wanted to hit free agency right now due to the pure uncertainty.

This has forced one of the shallowest free-agent markets in recent MLB history. That said, there are still some diamonds in the rough. Here’s the most underrated available player at each position.

Pitcher: Nick Martinez

At 36 and in his ninth year in the majors, starting pitcher Nick Martinez set a career high in innings pitched. His 2026 season with the Tampa Bay Rays didn’t reverse the clock on a past prime; instead, it set a new precedent.

The starting pitching class is by far the deepest of this free agency. It’s highlighted by top names like Tarik Skubal, Michael King and Freddy Peralta, but teams could find relative production at a far lower price with Martinez. As he enters his age-37 season, clubs are getting a low-risk, short-term deal with a pitcher who’s hitting his stride.

Catcher: Ryan Jeffers

Catchers never hit free agency. The sole importance of the position makes teams lock them down long-term. Since this batch of catchers hitting the market isn’t too different from normal, Ryan Jeffers is both an underrated player and the top catching asset.

Jeffers will be 30 years old come next season, opening the potential of a big deal and a slight overpay. He’s never been exceedingly productive at the plate, but did take a step forward last year.

Although he’s below-average defensively, Jeffers was among the most valuable catchers in ABS challenges. This offseason will be the first to see how clubs treasure positive ABS contributions.

First Base: Nathaniel Lowe

Nathaniel Lowe won’t make an eye-grabbing play or hit a clutch home run, but he will help your team win.

Lowe has been deadly consistent over the last four seasons. He’s hit between 16 and 18 home runs each year since 2023 while staying smart at the plate with plus-average. He also proved he can step up to bigger moments and helped the Cleveland Guardians reach the ALCS in 2026, with nine hits and five RBI in October.

Like Martinez, Lowe is a cheap, low-risk add. He doesn’t chase or whiff much, and he’s a bothersome out for opposing teams.

Second Base: Gleyber Torres

We’re going full Billy Beane Moneyball with this one. 

Gleyber Torres is entering his 10th season in Major League Baseball this year. Although his OPS hasn’t returned to his 2023 form, Torres has excelled at something else in the back half of his career: getting on base.

Each of the last two seasons, Torres has been within the top 5% in baseball in BB%. His eye for the strike zone has become more and more beneficial, and his chase rate keeps getting better and better.

Shortstop: Mauricio Dubon

The available shortstops this winter are scarce, so Mauricio Dubon could get a handful of attention. 

He provides an affordable upgrade defensively for any team seeking one. Although he doesn’t hit overly well, Dubon’s been within the top 10% of the best K% each of the last four years.

There are rumors that the Texas Rangers are shopping star shortstop Corey Seager, so Dubon could be a sufficient replacement for teams that miss out.

Third Base: Eugenio Suarez

Don’t forget about Eugenio Suarez yet.

Just two seasons ago, he hit 49 home runs. Although his 2026 season went nowhere as planned, getting placed on waivers in August after signing a one-year deal with the Cincinnati Reds, Suarez still has something left in him.

He could be a great short-term fit at third base, or even as a designated hitter, for any club seeking a bump in power.

Outfielders: Ian Happ, Randal Grichuk and Lane Thomas

Ian Happ is entering free agency for the first time in his 10-year career, and still provides some of the best defense in baseball at left field. He’s won four Gold Gloves in the last five years. If he can tap back into hitting doubles, his average will return to form, but his defense alone warrants a contract. 

While Happ departs from the Chicago Cubs, 35-year-old Randal Grichuk had a career revitalization eight miles south of Wrigley Field. After getting traded from the New York Yankees to the Chicago White Sox at the deadline, Grichuk ended with a career-high OPS in his 13th season. He won’t get much attention, but could be an underrated short-term option.

Lastly is Lane Thomas, who’s entering his age-31 season. Thomas is undervalued for the tools he provides outside of his swing, with positive baserunning and arm strength. He hits far better against left-handed pitching, so teams could sign Thomas and use him as a platoon in the outfield.

The Daily Diehard Newsletter

Join the Diehards!

Available 5 days a week in 5 minutes or less

Select list(s):

We don’t spam! Unsubscribe at any time

Share

Leave a comment

Related Articles
Aug 28, 2026; Bronx, New York, USA; New York Yankees first baseman Paul Goldschmidt (48) hits a solo home run against the Boston Red Sox during the fourth inning at Yankee Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Tom Horak-Imagn Images
MLBTrending

Paul Goldschmidt Has Already Earned His Place in Cooperstown

Veteran first baseman Paul Goldschmidt has entered free agency for the third...

Sep 29, 2026; Bronx, New York, USA; New York Yankees starting pitcher Cam Schlittler (31) pitches against the Boston Red Sox during the first inning of game one of the Wildcard round of the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Yankee Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-Imagn Images
MLB

Is Cam Schlittler the Yankees New Ace?

Gerrit Cole is back. Max Fried is here. But when the Yankees...

Aug 26, 2026; Cumberland, Georgia, USA; Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Evan Phillips (59) throws against the Atlanta Braves in the seventh inning at Truist Park. Mandatory Credit: Colin Hubbard-Imagn Images
MLBTrending

Assessing Evan Phillips’ Singing With The Atlanta Braves

The Atlanta Braves signed Evan Phillips to a three-year, $35 million contract,...

Oct 7, 2026; Bronx, New York, USA; New York Yankees shortstop George Lombard Jr. (96) high fives outfielder Aaron Judge before game three of the ALDS for the 2026 MLB Playoffs against the Tampa Bay Rays at Yankee Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-Imagn Images
MLB

Which Trade Candidates Should the Yankees Target?

The New York Yankees don’t seem very interested in this year’s free-agent...