AFCAFC EastNFLPatriots

The Jerod Mayo Era Was a Rudderless Ship

Share
Share

Two hours after the New England Patriots victory against AFC East rival Buffalo Bills, ESPN’s Adam Schefter announced the news that had become expected:

Shortly after the news was announced, Chairman and CEO Robert Kraft released a statement that raised more questions than answers.

Most importantly, Kraft admitted he made a mistake hiring Mayo. Kraft stated that he feared in recent years that Mayo would be poached by another team to become their head coach, therefore he committed to him being the successor to the legendary Bill Belichick.

It was one of the worst decisions the franchise had made.

The Jerod Mayo Era

Mayo was not ready to be head coach whatsoever. His entire professional playing and coaching career had been with one team. All other 31 head coaches in the league have spent time with multiple programs, learning under different coaches, except for Mayo, who knew practically nothing outside of the Patriot Way.

The former Patriots linebacker has also only coached for six years. This slim history alone explains was not even close to the right hire for New England:

  • As a coach:
    • New England Patriots (2019–2023) 
      • Inside linebackers coach
    • New England Patriots (2024)
      • Head coach

A consistent topic around social media has been “what Jerod Mayo was supposed to do.” The Patriots had the worst roster in the league and made practically no moves in the offseason. A fair argument.

That does not mean the coach is safe. 

Jerod Mayo’s Mistakes

Mayo’s tenure was filled with throwing players under the bus, players mouthing off on social media and to the media, making statements, and then walking back on them with no clear vision whatsoever. He took zero accountability for anything that happened and even went on throwing his offensive coordinator, Alex Van Pelt, under the bus for not running Drake Maye in short yardage.

@nbcsboston

“You said it. I didn’t” Jerod Mayo responds to why the Patriots don’t run Drake Maye despite his ability to run well

♬ original sound – NBC Sports Boston

He walked back on that comment a few days later.

After the team’s sixth straight loss, Mayo called the Patriots a “soft team across the board.”

He walked back on those comments a day later, saying they were “playing soft at the moment.”

The former Tennessee Vol was a mess with the media all season, which was finally capped off in his final presser.

Mayo had been wearing a blue pin for Robert Kraft’s “Stand Up to Jewish Hate” campaign all season. He did not wear it in his final game.

When asked why he did not wear it, he stated, “I apologize for not having it visible. You can make a story about it if you want to.”

Talent Level

The on-field talent was not good, either.

The team was in the top 12 in penalties after being in the bottom eight in the previous season. Though their offense improved from 13.9 points per game (32/32) a season ago to 17.0 per game (29/32), that has less to do with Mayo than it does with having Drake Maye instead of Bailey Zappe and Mac Jones.

Speaking of Maye, Mayo also sat him for the first five games of the season in favor of journeyman Jacoby Brissett. With Brissett as the starter, the team averaged 12.4 points per game, but with Maye in, the number jumped to 18.7 points per game over the final twelve games.

Maye was significantly better than anything Brissett had to offer. After becoming the starter, Maye only had three games with less than 200 yards, one of them being a game he left early due to injury. Maye’s rushing ability was also a big addition to the offense, rushing for 421 total yards.

Jacoby Brissett did not pass for more than 168 yards. He had 62 total rushing yards. 

The Defense Was Not Good, Either

The defense was utterly embarrassing.

Jerod Mayo is a defensive head coach. He prided himself on the defensive side of the ball, as that is where he held a job before becoming head coach.

The Patriots were dead last in sacks. Their opponents’ points per game increased from 21.5 to 24.5. They were in the top five in rush yards allowed last season. They were in the bottom ten this season.

The End

Finally, Mayo cost the team the number one pick. A loss to the Buffalo Bills in the season finale would give the Patriots the top selection in the draft for the first time in 30 years. The Patriots won.

Mayo was all smiles.

The Patriots were a rudderless ship all season. The team had no clear direction, even with a quarterback they selected in the top three. They had no identity whatsoever, and that rookie quarterback was the only reason many tuned in to watch this team week after week.

What Now?

The Patriots now turn to interviews for head coaches. They will be one of the bigger jobs on the market this offseason, with Drake Maye, the No. 4 pick, and $133 million in cap space.

Two prominent names come to mind: Former Tennessee Titans Head Coach Mike Vrabel, and Detroit Lions Offensive Coordinator Ben Johnson.

Mike Vrabel

Vrabel feels like the obvious outcome. He has plenty of experience in the NFL, a former Coach of the Year winner, and is close with the Patriots organization. In fact, part of the reason he was fired from the Titans was because he was at a Patriots Hall of Fame ceremony during the Titans’ bye week.

The Athletic’s Chad Graff reported that Vrabel has been extremely interested in the Patriots job and would be very open to it.

Close with the Kraft family, experienced, checks off multiple boxes for the Patriots.

Ben Johnson

Ben Johnson has been incredible for the Lions. The Lions’ offense is in the top five in nearly every major category, and they lead the league in points per game (33.2) by three points.

Johnson’s offense has also been extremely fun, with plays ranging from fake fumbles to offensive linemen lining up at receiver.

Johnson might not check the experience as a head coach box or the closeness with the Krafts as Vrabel does, but there is much to like about him.

A UNC graduate who studied at Boston College, Johnson is extremely close with Executive Vice President of Player Personnel Eliot Wolf and is a big fan of Drake Maye.

Johnson has been extremely picky with the teams he will give a chance to, and the Patriots are one of the two he has. The Lions’ offensive genius was one of the top candidates on the market last season but shockingly chose to stay in Detroit.

One might ask— did the hiring of Jerod Mayo cause him to return to the Lions?

The Patriots will most likely come to a decision in the following months. We’ll be following the process closely.

The Daily Diehard Newsletter

Join the Diehards!

Available 5 days a week in 5 minutes or less

Select list(s):

We don’t spam! Unsubscribe at any time

Share
Written by
Owen O'Connor

Boston, MA. Elon ‘28. @joemazzulla on Twitter, owenoc06 on IG. Covering the Celtics and Hornets.

Leave a comment

Related Articles
Nov 5, 2026; Baltimore, Maryland, USA; Baltimore Ravens running back Derrick Henry (22) carries the ball in the first quarter against the Jacksonville Jaguars at M&T Bank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: James Lang-Imagn Images
AFCAFC NorthFeaturedNFLRavensTrending

Can the Ravens Make a Playoff Push Without Lamar Jackson?

On Sunday, Nov. 8, Ian Rapoport talked to Baltimore Ravens quarterback Lamar...

Nov 8, 2026; Madrid, ESP; Cincinnati Bengal fans celebrate after their team defeated the against the Atlanta Falcons at Bernabeu Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images
NFL

NFL in Madrid: How the Fans Experienced America’s Sport

Passionate fans and packed-out events created an unforgettable fan experience during last...

Aug 6, 2026; Canton, Ohio, USA; Arizona Cardinals quarterback Carson Beck (19) warms up before playing the the Carolina Panthers at Tom Benson Hall of Fame Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images
CardinalsNFCNFC WestNFLTrending

Carson Beck Will Have a Rigorous Debut

The time has arrived for the Cardinals. An early birthday gift for...

Tennessee Titans safety Amani Hooker (37) celebrates an interception in the third quarter of the NFL Week 8 game between the Cincinnati Bengals and the Tennessee Titans at Paycor Stadium in Cincinnati on Sunday, Nov. 1, 2026. The Bengals played to a 43-36 overtime win against the Titans.
AFCAFC EastBillsNFL

Amani Hooker Is the Perfect Fit for the Buffalo Bills

At Tuesday’s trade deadline, the Buffalo Bills acquired Amani Hooker and a...